Hello Casey! Tinctures fairly often flip brown (the liquid and herbs), so that portion Seems all right. I’m unsure about the faint rotting scent although. I just went by and sniffed my selection of tinctures and they've various smells – many of the oldest kinds just scent like potent https://eduardoloaif.bcbloggers.com/21433789/learn-all-about-lemon-balm-options